philosophy meta-forum

CDJ having a fit on twitter...

Nuel

120 day(s) ago

a) This is hardly a "fit"

b) You'd be pissed too if someone published your data without even talking to you about it

c) You'd be pissed too if you got shit in the mail from Peter Auduren

Keith

Rumor, FWIW, is that David Barnett (ex-Colorado) did it. Barnett has a history of sending shit to people in mail.

Radovan

120 day(s) ago

a) This is hardly a "fit"

b) You'd be pissed too if someone published your data without even talking to you about it

c) You'd be pissed too if you got shit in the mail from Peter Auduren

Keith

Rumor, FWIW, is that David Barnett (ex-Colorado) did it. Barnett has a history of sending shit to people in mail.

Nuel

That sounds super credible.

Emile

120 day(s) ago

a) This is hardly a "fit"

b) You'd be pissed too if someone published your data without even talking to you about it

c) You'd be pissed too if you got shit in the mail from Peter Auduren

Keith

Rumor, FWIW, is that David Barnett (ex-Colorado) did it. Barnett has a history of sending shit to people in mail.

Nuel

Bullshit.

Btw, it's not 'Auduren' but 'Aduren'. It's easy to remember because it's 'Neruda' spelled backwards. Unrelatedly, you know who's a fan of Pablo Neruda? Some dude who runs a philosophy blog.

Jaegwon

119 day(s) ago

That CDJ passage from DN is comedy gold. The lengths to which she will go to avoid the most obvious explanation, that everyone already knows is true anyway. But then again, maybe it's worth it for these people. By whipping up this frenzy they've managed to do quite well for themselves with little philosophical accomplishments under their belts. If we don't stop them now that sanctimonious AA hire from Chapel Hill is going to get her way with quotas in journals too.

Frank

Actually, I feel like she did the world a big favor. Because the quota idea has zero chance of gaining real traction, and the proposal is a nice thing to be able to point to. That is: politically it's a bit of a disaster for The Cause.

Although, if I'm honest with myself, I've been badly wrong about things like this before. Recently.

Bernard

119 day(s) ago

Sorry: Ann Arbor, not Chapel Hill.

Frank

What's this a reference to? If some Michigan graduate advocated journal quotas I missed it. Link?

Raimundo

119 day(s) ago

Sorry: Ann Arbor, not Chapel Hill.

Frank

What's this a reference to? If some Michigan graduate advocated journal quotas I missed it. Link?

Bernard

Michigan faculty.

Philippa

119 day(s) ago

Sorry: Ann Arbor, not Chapel Hill.

Frank

What's this a reference to? If some Michigan graduate advocated journal quotas I missed it. Link?

Bernard

Michigan faculty.

Raimundo

Interesting; I second the call for a link!

Olympe

119 day(s) ago

http://paq.press.illinois.edu/31/2/krishnamurthy.html

Emil

119 day(s) ago

http://paq.press.illinois.edu/31/2/krishnamurthy.html

Olympe

Can someone post a PDF? I don't have access to this one.

Olympe

119 day(s) ago

There's one linked on her website here: https://meenakrishnamurthy.net/papers/

posts per page.